5 million people helped and counting  >  Call 1-888-888-CARE or Get Started Now
Article library
"I cook more dinners now and pack a lunch. Once you add up these savings, it's more than my monthly payment to CareOne!"Amy D., Woodruff, WICareOne Customer

Is Debt Consolidation A Good Idea?

If you have lots of debt, consolidation may save you time and money. Depending on your financial situation, there may be a solution that's right for you.

When you're struggling with lots of debt, debt consolidation may be an attractive solution. This term refers to combining your debts into one, and making one monthly payment to one creditor instead of making multiple payments to many creditors. You might even get out of debt faster and save money along the way. Debt consolidation comes in several forms, including credit counseling, balance transfers, and debt consolidation loans, so review your options carefully before making a decision.

Credit Counseling

When you're experiencing financial distress, these companies, also referred to as debt management companies, work with your creditors to restructure your unsecured debt. Through a debt relief plan, you make one monthly payment to them, and they pay your creditors. Companies that offer credit counseling do not loan you money. Instead, they negotiate with your current creditors to get you debt relief. Debt relief plans offer many benefits that may help with debt that is unsecured, such as:

  • Lowered monthly payments
  • Reduced or eliminated interest rates
  • Eliminated late fees

Balance Transfers

Transferring debt from a higher interest rate credit card to one with a lower rate can save you money. If you have a credit card with a low interest rate, you might consider transferring the balance from a high-rate credit card to the lower rate one. Or, you might apply for a new credit card with a lower interest rate. Be careful about introductory rates, also called teaser rates. Make sure you know what rate will be in effect after the first couple of months. If it's too high, this option may not be your best choice.

More About Teaser Interest Rates

Read the small print about credit card teaser rates. Teaser rates are often used to entice you to transfer a balance. Be sure to consider the following before you fill out the application:

  • Introductory rates typically last a short period of time
    • While some may last up to a year, it's not uncommon for the low introductory rate to expire after three or six months. After the introductory period is over, the interest rate will increase, sometimes to a very high rate.
  • The credit limit may not be high enough
    • Companies that offer balance transfers may not give you enough credit to transfer all of your debt. You'll be paying part of your debt at the original higher interest rate and part of it at the lower introductory rate.
  • There may be a balance transfer fee
    • Be sure to find out if there is a balance transfer fee and how much it is.

Debt Consolidation Loan

You can apply for a debt consolidation loan at most financial institutions, like banks, credit unions, and finance companies. There are two types of loans:

  • Unsecured - no collateral is required
  • Secured - collateral is required

Unsecured loans are commonly referred to as personal or signature loans. Examples of a secured loan include a home equity loan or a second mortgage since your home is used as collateral. To learn more about home equity loans, search the CareOne Credit Knowledge Center articles.

Is a Debt Consolidation Loan for You?

When you consolidate your existing debt and pay it off with a debt consolidation loan, you are trading several debts for a single debt. Even though you still have the same amount of debt, you may find this beneficial if you:

  • Get a loan with a lower interest rate than the rate(s) you are paying on your existing debts
    • This could save you money during the life of the loan depending on the term and amount of monthly payment. Don't forget to do your homework when investigating interest rates and monthly payments. A small difference can impact you greatly. For example:



Credit Card





Minimum Monthly Payment



Annual Percentage Rate (APR)







39 Years and

4 Months

4 Years


Amount Paid




Interest Paid



In this example, switching from a revolving credit card debt with 18% interest to an installment loan with 15% interest, and only increasing your monthly payment by $40, saves you over $12,000 in interest payments. Use the CareOne Credit calculators to compare credit card debt consolidation.

  • Close your credit card accounts
    • Paying off multiple credit cards with a debt consolidation loan may be a good idea, but be careful about racking up more debt on the open accounts. Think about keeping one account open for an emergency and closing the others. Not only will that ensure you're not tempted to charge additional items, it'll also look good to future lenders who review your credit report.

Be Careful with Finance Companies

If you're having difficulty getting a loan from a bank or a credit union because you have too much debt or a negative credit history, you may be able to get a loan from a finance company. Be careful if you decide to use finance companies. While finance companies typically make it easier for you to get a loan, there are things you should know, including:

  • Interest rates are often high
    • Higher interest rates typically mean a higher amount paid over the course of the loan.
  • Loan term may be lengthy
    • The longer length of the loan results in lower monthly payments, but it causes you to pay more interest.
  • Other fees may be present
    • It's not uncommon for finance companies to charge application or processing fees.
  • Future creditors may not look favorably on your credit profile
    • Even if your credit rating is good, potential creditors may perceive you as a bad risk if they see a finance company among your listed creditors. Since most people use finance companies if they don't qualify for a loan from a bank or a credit union, creditors may think you've had financial problems in the past.

If you're thinking about consolidating your debt, consider the pros and cons for your situation. Remember to shop carefully and compare costs. The U.S. Federal Trade Commission has several articles for consumers in debt, including Knee Deep in Debt and For People on Debt Management Plans: A Must-Do List.

Take control of your finances with our debt help tools. Use our calculators and budget planner to help you manage your money.

If you liked this you may also like:

  • You Asked, We Answered: The Truth About Debt Consolidation Companies

    Regardless of whether you binge on shopping or simply use credit cards to make ends meet, there may come a time when you need a financial intervention to help organize your bills, repay your debt, and improve your finances. For some, debt consolidation is the answer. But before you jump in head first, it's time for a course in Debt Consolidation 101.

  • Understanding Your Debt-To-Income Ratio

    Your Debt-to-Income Ratio is a crucial personal financial health indicator. Find out how to calculate it and what it means to you.

  • Debt Relief: Myth & Reality

    Debt relief comes in many forms- credit counseling, debt consolidation loans, settlement and even bankruptcy. Each solution will help you get out of debt, but the long term impacts and fees can vary greatly. Understand the myth and reality behind your debt relief options.

  • Do You Need Debt Relief?

    Feeling overwhelmed by your debts? Having trouble making ends meet? Unable to get ahead of your credit card debts? A Debt Relief plan may be your solution to getting control of your finances.

  • Debt Consolidation Loans: What to Consider When Weighing Your Options

    When faced with mounting bills, many consumers explore debt consolidation loans as a way to get their finances back on track as quickly as possible. And while a debt consolidation loan may be a great solution for you, it's important to weigh your options to determine the best plan for you and your specific financial situation.

Begin our online process to see your personalized savings.

Start Now

Back Print

Quizzes and Polls

What's your debt IQ? Take one of our quizzes and find out how much you know about financial fitness.

Take the Quiz Now!

Stay On Track

Subscribe to our newsletter, packed with great articles, tips, and advice to help you make the most of your money.

Subscribe Now!

Crunch the Numbers

Our calculators can help you figure out your budget, credit card payments, mortgage, and more!

Learn More
Debt Help - CareOne Debt Relief Services
Offering CareOne Debt Relief Services: