Raise Your Deductibles and Lower Your Premiums!

The deductibles on your current automobile insurance policy might be costing more than you think. A small adjustment now may save you money over time.

Your deductible is the dollar amount you agree to pay out-of-pocket each time you cause an accident and make a claim under your collision coverage. The same applies to your comprehensive coverage. (For a general explanation of automobile insurance coverage, see the Better Business Bureau article about thebasics of auto insurance.) In other words, your deductible is the predetermined amount the insurance company "deducts" from the total bill and you pay that amount. If the total damage comes to $3,000 and your deductible is $250, you would pay $250 and the insurance company would pay the remaining balance. In another example, if the total damage is $200 and your deductible is still $250, you would be responsible for paying the $200.

Choosing the Best Deductible for You

Once you've found a reputable automobile insurance carrier and have decided how much coverage is right for you, the decision about deductibles is the next step. If you are involved in an automobile accident, your collision coverage will pay for the damage to your vehicle; that is, after you pay your deductible for that accident. The comprehensive portion of your insurance provides coverage for damage to your car caused from events other than accidents. For example, a rock cracking your windshield on the highway or a branch falling on your parked car, would be covered through your comprehensive coverage. It is not necessary to apply the same deductible to both your collision and comprehensive coverage. The cost to repair the damage caused by a "collision" is potentially much greater than the non-collision events. You might be able to lower your insurance costs by raising the deductible on your collision coverage and taking advantage of discounts offered by your insurance carrier. So, make the decision about your deductible amounts for collision and comprehensive coverage separately.

Many of us tend to choose the lowest deductible possible, not realizing we could be saving a considerable amount of money each year if we accept a higher deductible. One word of caution here; if you won't be able to manage the larger deductible payment, if and when an accident happens, it doesn't make sense to raise your deductible amount. Another factor to consider is your driving record. If you have a history of accidents, you'll want to plan ahead based on those past trends.

The Numbers Tell the Story

As you shop for insurance, consider creating a table to compare the long-term impact of paying a higher deductible. In the following examples, the numbers used are for illustrative purposes only and do not constitute any actual premium amounts. Insert your own insurance figures into the table to determine your potential savings. Start first by looking at your projected costs on a per year basis:

$250 Deductible

$500 Deductible

Annual Savings

Average Annual Savings

Year One Premiums Paid

$1,000

$800

n/a

n/a

One Accident-Deductible Paid

$250

$500

n/a

n/a

Year One Cost

$1,250

$1,300

-$50

$0

In this example, during the first year there is no benefit to raising the deductible. Now, look at how much money you can save over time if you increase your deductible:

$250 Deductible

$500 Deductible

2-Year Savings

Average Annual Savings

Years One & Two Premiums Paid

$2,000

$1,600

n/a

n/a

One Accident - Deductible Paid

$250

$500

n/a

n/a

Years One & Two Cost

$2,250

$2,100

$150

$75

Over a two-year period, accepting the higher deductible can save you money. What happens if you look at five years at once?

$250 Deductible

$500 Deductible

5-Year Savings

Average Annual Savings

Years One-Five Premiums Paid

$5,000

$4,000

n/a

n/a

One Accident - Deductible Paid

$250

$500

n/a

n/a

Years One-Five Cost

$5,250

$4,500

$750

$150

With the addition of each accident-free year, the savings continue to add up.

As you evaluate your automobile insurance options, build a simple table like the examples above to understand your potential costs and savings. Don't forget to take your driving history into consideration when you make your decision about your deductible. For more tips on how to lower your car insurance costs, see the advice from someone who works in the insurance industry:10 Expert Tips for Saving on Car Insurance.

Take control of your finances with our debt help tools. Use our calculators and budget planner to help you manage your money.



Related Insurance Articles:

  • Understanding Excess Liability Protection - What is underlying liability and is it enough insurance coverage? You may find that you are better off with some Umbrella Liability Coverage which can come at a very affordable rate. Evaluate your situation and let's determine if you are in need of a little extra.

  • Protect your Personal Property for Insurance Purposes - Whether your insurance company reimburses you for the cost to replace your lost possessions will greatly depend on the inventory you complete. Discover how to create an inventory and what you should include in order to ensure its replacement.

  • How to Determine the Value of your Homeowner's Coverage - Does your homeowner's coverage provide enough protection to replace or repair your possessions? You can easily determine whether it does by reviewing how to establish its actual and replacement values, limitations, and the possible need for additional coverage.

 
 

Begin our online process to see your personalized savings.

 
Back    Print